Граф коммитов

769 Коммитов

Автор SHA1 Сообщение Дата
Jemma Issroff 85ea46730d Separate TS_IVC and TS_ICVARC in is_entries buffers
This allows us to treat cvar caches differently than ivar caches.
2022-07-18 14:06:30 -07:00
John Hawthorn b8247a1669 Correct comment explaining env flags [ci skip]
We use 4 values for env flags now, which also shifted over the frame
flags by one bit.
2022-07-14 09:59:34 -07:00
Aaron Patterson 8d63a04703 Flatten bitmap when there is only one element
We can avoid allocating a bitmap when the number of elements in the iseq
is fewer than the size of an iseq_bits_t
2022-06-23 16:52:00 -07:00
Aaron Patterson 1ccdb1a251 Update vm_core.h
Co-authored-by: Tomás Coêlho <36938811+tomascco@users.noreply.github.com>
2022-06-23 14:01:46 -07:00
Aaron Patterson e23540e566 Speed up ISeq by marking via bitmaps and IC rearranging
This commit adds a bitfield to the iseq body that stores offsets inside
the iseq buffer that contain values we need to mark.  We can use this
bitfield to mark objects instead of disassembling the instructions.

This commit also groups inline storage entries and adds a counter for
each entry.  This allows us to iterate and mark each entry without
disassembling instructions

Since we have a bitfield and grouped inline caches, we can mark all
VALUE objects associated with instructions without actually
disassembling the instructions at mark time.

[Feature #18875] [ruby-core:109042]
2022-06-23 14:01:46 -07:00
Koichi Sasada 08cee2bf80 altstack is native thread's attr
Move th->altstack to th->nt->altstack.
2022-05-24 17:50:49 +09:00
Koichi Sasada f3235ac095 add `rb_th_serial()`
`rb_th_serial(th)` returns th's serial for debug print purpose.
2022-05-24 10:06:51 +09:00
Koichi Sasada d9984f39d3 remove `NON_SCALAR_THREAD_ID` support
`NON_SCALAR_THREAD_ID` shows `pthread_t` is non-scalar (non-pointer)
and only s390x is known platform. However, the supporting code is
very complex and it is only used for deubg print information.

So this patch removes the support of `NON_SCALAR_THREAD_ID`
and make the code simple.
2022-05-24 10:06:51 +09:00
Koichi Sasada eab99b1d4b `rb_thread_t::serial` for debug
`rb_thread_t::serial` is auto-incremented serial number for
threads and it can overflow, it means the serial is not a ID
for each thread, it is only for debug print.

`RUBY_DEBUG_LOG` shows this information.

Also skip EC related information if EC is NULL. This patch
enable to use `RUBY_DEBUG_LOG` without setup EC.
2022-05-20 17:37:46 +09:00
Samuel Williams f626998c4f
Delete autoload data from global features after autoload has completed. (#5910)
* Update naming of critical section assertions macros.

* Improved locking for autoload.
2022-05-17 00:50:02 +12:00
Samuel Williams 32de6097b2
Fix various autoload race conditions. (#5898)
* Add RUBY_VM_CRITICAL_SECTION for detecting unexpected context switch.

* Prevent race between GC mark and autoload setup.

* Protect race on autoload state.

* Avoid potential race condition when allocating `autoload_featuremap`.

* Add NEWS entry for autoload fixes.
2022-05-15 16:07:12 +12:00
Alan Wu f90549cd38 Rust YJIT
In December 2021, we opened an [issue] to solicit feedback regarding the
porting of the YJIT codebase from C99 to Rust. There were some
reservations, but this project was given the go ahead by Ruby core
developers and Matz. Since then, we have successfully completed the port
of YJIT to Rust.

The new Rust version of YJIT has reached parity with the C version, in
that it passes all the CRuby tests, is able to run all of the YJIT
benchmarks, and performs similarly to the C version (because it works
the same way and largely generates the same machine code). We've even
incorporated some design improvements, such as a more fine-grained
constant invalidation mechanism which we expect will make a big
difference in Ruby on Rails applications.

Because we want to be careful, YJIT is guarded behind a configure
option:

```shell
./configure --enable-yjit # Build YJIT in release mode
./configure --enable-yjit=dev # Build YJIT in dev/debug mode
```

By default, YJIT does not get compiled and cargo/rustc is not required.
If YJIT is built in dev mode, then `cargo` is used to fetch development
dependencies, but when building in release, `cargo` is not required,
only `rustc`. At the moment YJIT requires Rust 1.60.0 or newer.

The YJIT command-line options remain mostly unchanged, and more details
about the build process are documented in `doc/yjit/yjit.md`.

The CI tests have been updated and do not take any more resources than
before.

The development history of the Rust port is available at the following
commit for interested parties:
1fd9573d8b

Our hope is that Rust YJIT will be compiled and included as a part of
system packages and compiled binaries of the Ruby 3.2 release. We do not
anticipate any major problems as Rust is well supported on every
platform which YJIT supports, but to make sure that this process works
smoothly, we would like to reach out to those who take care of building
systems packages before the 3.2 release is shipped and resolve any
issues that may come up.

[issue]: https://bugs.ruby-lang.org/issues/18481

Co-authored-by: Maxime Chevalier-Boisvert <maximechevalierb@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Noah Gibbs <the.codefolio.guy@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Kevin Newton <kddnewton@gmail.com>
2022-04-27 11:00:22 -04:00
Koichi Sasada 03d21a4fb0 introduce struct `rb_native_thread`
`rb_thread_t` contained `native_thread_data_t` to represent
thread implementation dependent data. This patch separates
them and rename it `rb_native_thread` and point it from
`rb_thraed_t`.

Now, 1 Ruby thread (`rb_thread_t`) has 1 native thread (`rb_native_thread`).
2022-04-23 03:08:27 +09:00
Koichi Sasada 1c4fc0241d rename thread internal naming
Now GVL is not process *Global* so this patch try to use
another words.

* `rb_global_vm_lock_t` -> `struct rb_thread_sched`
  * `gvl->owner` -> `sched->running`
  * `gvl->waitq` -> `sched->readyq`
* `rb_gvl_init` -> `rb_thread_sched_init`
* `gvl_destroy` -> `rb_thread_sched_destroy`
* `gvl_acquire` -> `thread_sched_to_running` # waiting -> ready -> running
* `gvl_release` -> `thread_sched_to_waiting` # running -> waiting
* `gvl_yield`   -> `thread_sched_yield`
* `GVL_UNLOCK_BEGIN` -> `THREAD_BLOCKING_BEGIN`
* `GVL_UNLOCK_END` -> `THREAD_BLOCKING_END`

* removed
  * `rb_ractor_gvl`
  * `rb_vm_gvl_destroy` (not used)

There are GVL functions such as `rb_thread_call_without_gvl()` yet
but I don't have good name to replace them. Maybe GVL stands for
"Greate Valuable Lock" or something like that.
2022-04-22 07:54:09 +09:00
Kevin Newton 6068da8937 Finer-grained constant cache invalidation (take 2)
This commit reintroduces finer-grained constant cache invalidation.
After 8008fb7 got merged, it was causing issues on token-threaded
builds (such as on Windows).

The issue was that when you're iterating through instruction sequences
and using the translator functions to get back the instruction structs,
you're either using `rb_vm_insn_null_translator` or
`rb_vm_insn_addr2insn2` depending if it's a direct-threading build.
`rb_vm_insn_addr2insn2` does some normalization to always return to
you the non-trace version of whatever instruction you're looking at.
`rb_vm_insn_null_translator` does not do that normalization.

This means that when you're looping through the instructions if you're
trying to do an opcode comparison, it can change depending on the type
of threading that you're using. This can be very confusing. So, this
commit creates a new translator function
`rb_vm_insn_normalizing_translator` to always return the non-trace
version so that opcode comparisons don't have to worry about different
configurations.

[Feature #18589]
2022-04-01 14:48:22 -04:00
Nobuyoshi Nakada 42a0bed351
Prefix ccan headers (#4568)
* Prefixed ccan headers

* Remove unprefixed names in ccan/build_assert

* Remove unprefixed names in ccan/check_type

* Remove unprefixed names in ccan/container_of

* Remove unprefixed names in ccan/list

Co-authored-by: Samuel Williams <samuel.williams@oriontransfer.co.nz>
2022-03-30 20:36:31 +13:00
Nobuyoshi Nakada 69967ee64e
Revert "Finer-grained inline constant cache invalidation"
This reverts commits for [Feature #18589]:
* 8008fb7352
  "Update formatting per feedback"
* 8f6eaca2e1
  "Delete ID from constant cache table if it becomes empty on ISEQ free"
* 629908586b
  "Finer-grained inline constant cache invalidation"

MSWin builds on AppVeyor have been crashing since the merger.
2022-03-25 20:29:09 +09:00
Kevin Newton 629908586b Finer-grained inline constant cache invalidation
Current behavior - caches depend on a global counter. All constant mutations cause caches to be invalidated.

```ruby
class A
  B = 1
end

def foo
  A::B # inline cache depends on global counter
end

foo # populate inline cache
foo # hit inline cache

C = 1 # global counter increments, all caches are invalidated

foo # misses inline cache due to `C = 1`
```

Proposed behavior - caches depend on name components. Only constant mutations with corresponding names will invalidate the cache.

```ruby
class A
  B = 1
end

def foo
  A::B # inline cache depends constants named "A" and "B"
end

foo # populate inline cache
foo # hit inline cache

C = 1 # caches that depend on the name "C" are invalidated

foo # hits inline cache because IC only depends on "A" and "B"
```

Examples of breaking the new cache:

```ruby
module C
  # Breaks `foo` cache because "A" constant is set and the cache in foo depends
  # on "A" and "B"
  class A; end
end

B = 1
```

We expect the new cache scheme to be invalidated less often because names aren't frequently reused. With the cache being invalidated less, we can rely on its stability more to keep our constant references fast and reduce the need to throw away generated code in YJIT.
2022-03-24 09:14:38 -07:00
Peter Zhu 5f10bd634f Add ISEQ_BODY macro
Use ISEQ_BODY macro to get the rb_iseq_constant_body of the ISeq. Using
this macro will make it easier for us to change the allocation strategy
of rb_iseq_constant_body when using Variable Width Allocation.
2022-03-24 10:03:51 -04:00
Yuta Saito 23de01c7aa [wasm] eval_inter.h gc.c vm_core.h: include wasm/setjmp.h instead of sysroot header 2022-01-19 11:19:06 +09:00
Koichi Sasada ad450c9fe5 make `overloaded_cme_table` truly weak key map
`overloaded_cme_table` keeps cme -> monly_cme pairs to manage
corresponding `monly_cme` for `cme`. The lifetime of the `monly_cme`
should be longer than `monly_cme`, but the previous patch losts the
reference to the living `monly_cme`.

Now `overloaded_cme_table` values are always root (keys are only weak
reference), it means `monly_cme` does not freed until corresponding
`cme` is invalidated.

To make managing easy, move `overloaded_cme_table` to `rb_vm_t`.
2021-12-21 15:21:30 +09:00
Koichi Sasada 2e6e2fd9da fix local TP memory leak
It free `rb_hook_list_t` itself if needed. To recognize the
need, this patch introduced `rb_hook_list_t::is_local` flag.

This patch is succession of https://github.com/ruby/ruby/pull/4652
2021-12-15 02:31:58 +09:00
Yusuke Endoh 8613c0c675 Introduce an option "--dump=insns_without_opt" for debugging purposes 2021-12-13 10:29:08 +09:00
Koichi Sasada b1b73936c1 `Primitive.mandatory_only?` for fast path
Compare with the C methods, A built-in methods written in Ruby is
slower if only mandatory parameters are given because it needs to
check the argumens and fill default values for optional and keyword
parameters (C methods can check the number of parameters with `argc`,
so there are no overhead). Passing mandatory arguments are common
(optional arguments are exceptional, in many cases) so it is important
to provide the fast path for such common cases.

`Primitive.mandatory_only?` is a special builtin function used with
`if` expression like that:

```ruby
  def self.at(time, subsec = false, unit = :microsecond, in: nil)
    if Primitive.mandatory_only?
      Primitive.time_s_at1(time)
    else
      Primitive.time_s_at(time, subsec, unit, Primitive.arg!(:in))
    end
  end
```

and it makes two ISeq,

```
  def self.at(time, subsec = false, unit = :microsecond, in: nil)
    Primitive.time_s_at(time, subsec, unit, Primitive.arg!(:in))
  end

  def self.at(time)
    Primitive.time_s_at1(time)
  end
```

and (2) is pointed by (1). Note that `Primitive.mandatory_only?`
should be used only in a condition of an `if` statement and the
`if` statement should be equal to the methdo body (you can not
put any expression before and after the `if` statement).

A method entry with `mandatory_only?` (`Time.at` on the above case)
is marked as `iseq_overload`. When the method will be dispatch only
with mandatory arguments (`Time.at(0)` for example), make another
method entry with ISeq (2) as mandatory only method entry and it
will be cached in an inline method cache.

The idea is similar discussed in https://bugs.ruby-lang.org/issues/16254
but it only checks mandatory parameters or more, because many cases
only mandatory parameters are given. If we find other cases (optional
or keyword parameters are used frequently and it hurts performance),
we can extend the feature.
2021-11-15 15:58:56 +09:00
Yuta Saito 8590d61ea9 Select including thread impl file at config time 2021-10-30 10:18:33 +09:00
Yusuke Endoh c1228f833c vm_core.h: Avoid unaligned access to ic_serial on 32-bit machine
This caused Bus error on 32 bit Solaris
2021-10-29 10:57:46 +09:00
Yusuke Endoh 86e3d77abb
Make Coverage suspendable (#4856)
* Make Coverage suspendable

Add `Coverage.suspend`, `Coverage.resume` and some methods.

[Feature #18176] [ruby-core:105321]
2021-10-25 20:00:51 +09:00
Nobuyoshi Nakada 7459a32af3 suppress warnings for probable NULL dererefences 2021-10-24 19:24:50 +09:00
Koichi Sasada c7550537f1 `RubyVM.keep_script_lines`
`RubyVM.keep_script_lines` enables to keep script lines
for each ISeq and AST. This feature is for debugger/REPL
support.

```ruby
RubyVM.keep_script_lines = true
RubyVM::keep_script_lines = true

eval("def foo = nil\ndef bar = nil")
pp RubyVM::InstructionSequence.of(method(:foo)).script_lines
```
2021-10-21 16:17:39 +09:00
Alan Wu 5906a5a732 Add comments about special runtime routines YJIT calls
When YJIT make calls to routines without reconstructing interpreter
state through jit_prepare_routine_call(), it relies on the routine to
never allocate, raise, and push/pop control frames. Comment about this
on the routines that YJTI calls.

This is probably something we should dynamically verify on debug builds.
It's hard to statically verify this as it requires verifying all
functions in the call tree. Maybe something to look at in the future.
2021-10-20 18:19:43 -04:00
Alan Wu 7c08538aa3 Cleanup diff against upstream. Add comments
I did a `git diff --stat` against upstream and looked at all the files
that are outside of YJIT to come up with these minor changes.
2021-10-20 18:19:42 -04:00
Alan Wu b626dd7211 YJIT: Fancier opt_getinlinecache
Make sure `opt_getinlinecache` is in a block all on its own, and
invalidate it from the interpreter when `opt_setinlinecache`.
It will recompile with a filled cache the second time around.
This lets YJIT runs well when the IC for constant is cold.
2021-10-20 18:19:33 -04:00
Jose Narvaez 4e2eb7695e Yet Another Ruby JIT!
Renaming uJIT to YJIT. AKA s/ujit/yjit/g.
2021-10-20 18:19:31 -04:00
Maxime Chevalier-Boisvert abc016ad2c WIP refactor block lists to use darray 2021-10-20 18:19:30 -04:00
Alan Wu c02517bacb Tie lifetime of uJIT blocks to iseqs
* Tie lifetime of uJIT blocks to iseqs

   Blocks weren't being freed when iseqs are collected.

* Add rb_dary. Use it for method dependency table

* Keep track of blocks per iseq

  Remove global version_tbl

* Block version bookkeeping fix

* dary -> darray

* free ujit_blocks

* comment about size of ujit_blocks
2021-10-20 18:19:29 -04:00
Maxime Chevalier-Boisvert 9d8cc01b75 WIP JIT-to-JIT returns 2021-10-20 18:19:28 -04:00
Jeremy Evans 79a4484a07 Do not load file with same realpath twice when requiring
This fixes issues with paths being loaded twice in certain cases
when symlinks are used.

It took me multiple attempts to get this working.  My original
attempt tried to convert paths to realpaths before adding them
to $LOADED_FEATURES.  Unfortunately, this doesn't work well
with the loaded feature index, which is based off load paths
and not realpaths. While I was able to get require working, I'm
fairly sure the loaded feature index was not being used as
expected, which would have significant performance implications.
Additionally, I was never able to get that approach working with
autoload when autoloading a non-realpath file. It also broke
some specs.

This takes a more conservative approach. Directly before loading the
file, if the file with the same realpath has been required, the
loading of the file is skipped. The realpaths are stored as
fstrings in a hidden hash.

When rebuilding the loaded feature index, the hash of realpaths
is also rebuilt.  I'm guessing this makes rebuilding process
slower, but I don think that is a hot path. In general, modifying
loaded features is only done when reloading, and that tends to be
in non-production environments.

Change test_require_with_loaded_features_pop test to use 30 threads
and 300 iterations, instead of 4 threads and 1000 iterations.
I saw only sporadic failures with 4/1000, but consistent failures
30/300 threads. These failures were due to the fact that the
concurrent deletions from $LOADED_FEATURES in other threads can
result in rb_ary_entry returning nil when rebuilding the loaded
features index.

To avoid concurrency issues when rebuilding the loaded features
index, the building of the index itself is left alone, and
afterwards, a separate loop is done on a copy of the loaded feature
snapshot in order to rebuild the realpaths hash.

Fixes [Bug #17885]
2021-10-02 05:51:29 -09:00
Jeremy Evans 162ad65fdd Revert "Do not load file with same realpath twice when requiring"
This reverts commit ddb85c5d2b.

This commit causes unexpected warnings in TestTranscode#test_loading_race
occasionally in CI.
2021-09-18 17:37:35 -07:00
Jeremy Evans ddb85c5d2b Do not load file with same realpath twice when requiring
This fixes issues with paths being loaded twice in certain cases
when symlinks are used.

It took me multiple attempts to get this working.  My original
attempt tried to convert paths to realpaths before adding them
to $LOADED_FEATURES.  Unfortunately, this doesn't work well
with the loaded feature index, which is based off load paths
and not realpaths. While I was able to get require working, I'm
fairly sure the loaded feature index was not being used as
expected, which would have significant performance implications.
Additionally, I was never able to get that approach working with
autoload when autoloading a non-realpath file. It also broke
some specs.

This takes a more conservative approach. Directly before loading the
file, if the file with the same realpath has been required, the
loading of the file is skipped. The realpaths are stored as
fstrings in a hidden hash.

When rebuilding the loaded feature index, the hash of realpaths
is also rebuilt.  I'm guessing this makes rebuilding process
slower, but I don think that is a hot path. In general, modifying
loaded features is only done when reloading, and that tends to be
in non-production environments.

Change test_require_with_loaded_features_pop test to use 30 threads
and 300 iterations, instead of 4 threads and 1000 iterations.
I saw only sporadic failures with 4/1000, but consistent failures
30/300 threads. These failures were due to the fact that the
concurrent deletions from $LOADED_FEATURES in other threads can
result in rb_ary_entry returning nil when rebuilding the loaded
features index.

To avoid concurrency issues when rebuilding the loaded features
index, the building of the index itself is left alone, and
afterwards, a separate loop is done on a copy of the loaded feature
snapshot in order to rebuild the realpaths hash.

Fixes [Bug #17885]
2021-09-18 07:05:23 -09:00
卜部昌平 dddc618d30 suppress GCC's -Wsuggest-attribute=format
I was not aware of this because I use clang these days.
2021-09-10 20:00:06 +09:00
Yusuke Endoh f336a3eb6c Use free instead of xfree to free altstack
The altstack memory of a thread may be free'ed even after the VM is
destructed. After that, GC is no longer available, so calling xfree
may lead to a segfault.

This changeset uses the bare free function to free the altstack memory
instead of xfree. [Bug #18126]
2021-09-06 14:22:24 +09:00
Nobuyoshi Nakada 28d03ee776 Remove root_jmpbuf in rb_thread_struct
It has not been used since 1b82c877df.
2021-08-10 19:08:38 +09:00
Samuel Williams 42130a64f0
Replace copy coroutine with pthread implementation. 2021-07-01 11:23:03 +12:00
eileencodes b91b3bc771 Add a cache for class variables
Redo of 34a2acdac788602c14bf05fb616215187badd504 and
931138b00696419945dc03e10f033b1f53cd50f3 which were reverted.

GitHub PR #4340.

This change implements a cache for class variables. Previously there was
no cache for cvars. Cvar access is slow due to needing to travel all the
way up th ancestor tree before returning the cvar value. The deeper the
ancestor tree the slower cvar access will be.

The benefits of the cache are more visible with a higher number of
included modules due to the way Ruby looks up class variables. The
benchmark here includes 26 modules and shows with the cache, this branch
is 6.5x faster when accessing class variables.

```
compare-ruby: ruby 3.1.0dev (2021-03-15T06:22:34Z master 9e5105c) [x86_64-darwin19]
built-ruby: ruby 3.1.0dev (2021-03-15T12:12:44Z add-cache-for-clas.. c6be009) [x86_64-darwin19]

|         |compare-ruby|built-ruby|
|:--------|-----------:|---------:|
|vm_cvar  |      5.681M|   36.980M|
|         |           -|     6.51x|
```

Benchmark.ips calling `ActiveRecord::Base.logger` from within a Rails
application. ActiveRecord::Base.logger has 71 ancestors. The more
ancestors a tree has, the more clear the speed increase. IE if Base had
only one ancestor we'd see no improvement. This benchmark is run on a
vanilla Rails application.

Benchmark code:

```ruby
require "benchmark/ips"
require_relative "config/environment"

Benchmark.ips do |x|
  x.report "logger" do
    ActiveRecord::Base.logger
  end
end
```

Ruby 3.0 master / Rails 6.1:

```
Warming up --------------------------------------
              logger   155.251k i/100ms
Calculating -------------------------------------
```

Ruby 3.0 with cvar cache /  Rails 6.1:

```
Warming up --------------------------------------
              logger     1.546M i/100ms
Calculating -------------------------------------
              logger     14.857M (± 4.8%) i/s -     74.198M in   5.006202s
```

Lastly we ran a benchmark to demonstate the difference between master
and our cache when the number of modules increases. This benchmark
measures 1 ancestor, 30 ancestors, and 100 ancestors.

Ruby 3.0 master:

```
Warming up --------------------------------------
            1 module     1.231M i/100ms
          30 modules   432.020k i/100ms
         100 modules   145.399k i/100ms
Calculating -------------------------------------
            1 module     12.210M (± 2.1%) i/s -     61.553M in   5.043400s
          30 modules      4.354M (± 2.7%) i/s -     22.033M in   5.063839s
         100 modules      1.434M (± 2.9%) i/s -      7.270M in   5.072531s

Comparison:
            1 module: 12209958.3 i/s
          30 modules:  4354217.8 i/s - 2.80x  (± 0.00) slower
         100 modules:  1434447.3 i/s - 8.51x  (± 0.00) slower
```

Ruby 3.0 with cvar cache:

```
Warming up --------------------------------------
            1 module     1.641M i/100ms
          30 modules     1.655M i/100ms
         100 modules     1.620M i/100ms
Calculating -------------------------------------
            1 module     16.279M (± 3.8%) i/s -     82.038M in   5.046923s
          30 modules     15.891M (± 3.9%) i/s -     79.459M in   5.007958s
         100 modules     16.087M (± 3.6%) i/s -     81.005M in   5.041931s

Comparison:
            1 module: 16279458.0 i/s
         100 modules: 16087484.6 i/s - same-ish: difference falls within error
          30 modules: 15891406.2 i/s - same-ish: difference falls within error
```

Co-authored-by: Aaron Patterson <tenderlove@ruby-lang.org>
2021-06-18 10:02:44 -07:00
Nobuyoshi Nakada e03bf76b31
Pack iseq_inline_constant_cache_entry
Reordered iseq_inline_constant_cache_entry members not to exceed
the size of RValue.
2021-06-09 19:15:57 +09:00
Takashi Kokubun c32ce2cbf1
Clarify these are just for MJIT
and not for third-party libraries.

See: e6484a1530
2021-06-02 00:09:47 -07:00
Takashi Kokubun e1b03b0c2b
Enable VM_ASSERT in --jit CIs (#4543) 2021-06-01 00:15:51 -07:00
NARUSE, Yui 46655156dc Add Thread#native_thread_id [Feature #17853] 2021-05-26 15:14:11 +09:00
Takashi Kokubun 141861a222
Update a comment about what 'inline' attr means 2021-05-21 23:27:36 -07:00
Aaron Patterson 07f055bb13
Revert "Filling cache values on cvar write"
This reverts commit 08de37f9fa.
This reverts commit e8ae922b62.
2021-05-11 13:31:00 -07:00