diff --git a/src/amo/components/FlagReview/index.js b/src/amo/components/FlagReview/index.js
index ba834ddc4b..b825fcbd7c 100644
--- a/src/amo/components/FlagReview/index.js
+++ b/src/amo/components/FlagReview/index.js
@@ -14,11 +14,14 @@ import type { ElementEvent, HTMLElementEventHandler } from 'amo/types/dom';
 import type { ErrorHandlerType } from 'amo/types/errorHandler';
 import type { DispatchFunc } from 'amo/types/redux';
 
+import './styles.scss';
+
 type Props = {|
   buttonText: string,
   reason: FlagReviewReasonType,
   review: UserReviewType,
   wasFlaggedText: string,
+  disabled?: boolean,
 |};
 
 type PropsFromState = {|
@@ -47,7 +50,8 @@ export class FlagReviewBase extends React.Component<InternalProps> {
   };
 
   renderControls(): React.Node {
-    const { errorHandler, flagState, buttonText, wasFlaggedText } = this.props;
+    const { disabled, errorHandler, flagState, buttonText, wasFlaggedText } =
+      this.props;
 
     if (flagState) {
       if (flagState.inProgress && !errorHandler.hasError()) {
@@ -63,6 +67,7 @@ export class FlagReviewBase extends React.Component<InternalProps> {
         className="FlagReview-button"
         onClick={this.onClick}
         type="button"
+        disabled={!!disabled}
       >
         {buttonText}
       </button>
diff --git a/src/amo/components/FlagReview/styles.scss b/src/amo/components/FlagReview/styles.scss
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..4bc2d66213
--- /dev/null
+++ b/src/amo/components/FlagReview/styles.scss
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
+@import '~amo/css/styles';
+
+.FlagReview-button[disabled] {
+  @include disabled;
+
+  &:hover,
+  &:focus,
+  &:active {
+    color: initial !important;
+  }
+}
diff --git a/src/amo/components/FlagReviewMenu/index.js b/src/amo/components/FlagReviewMenu/index.js
index 1af0c0285a..cee56d560d 100644
--- a/src/amo/components/FlagReviewMenu/index.js
+++ b/src/amo/components/FlagReviewMenu/index.js
@@ -65,8 +65,16 @@ export class FlagReviewMenuBase extends React.Component<InternalProps> {
       'A user cannot flag their own review.',
     );
 
+    const enableFeatureFeedbackFormLinks = config.get(
+      'enableFeatureFeedbackFormLinks',
+    );
+
+    const disableItemsForUnauthenticatedUsers = enableFeatureFeedbackFormLinks
+      ? !siteUser
+      : false;
+
     let items;
-    if (!siteUser) {
+    if (!enableFeatureFeedbackFormLinks && !siteUser) {
       items = [
         <ListItem key="login-required">
           <AuthenticateButton
@@ -87,13 +95,14 @@ export class FlagReviewMenuBase extends React.Component<InternalProps> {
             review={review}
             buttonText={i18n.gettext('This is spam')}
             wasFlaggedText={i18n.gettext('Flagged as spam')}
+            disabled={disableItemsForUnauthenticatedUsers}
           />
         </ListItem>,
         <ListItem
           className="FlagReviewMenu-flag-language-item"
           key="flag-language"
         >
-          {config.get('enableFeatureFeedbackFormLinks') ? (
+          {enableFeatureFeedbackFormLinks ? (
             <Link to={`/feedback/review/${review.id}/`}>
               {i18n.gettext('This contains inappropriate language')}
             </Link>
@@ -124,6 +133,7 @@ export class FlagReviewMenuBase extends React.Component<InternalProps> {
               wasFlaggedText={i18n.gettext(
                 'Flagged as a bug report or support request',
               )}
+              disabled={disableItemsForUnauthenticatedUsers}
             />
           </ListItem>
         ),
diff --git a/src/amo/components/TooltipMenu/styles.scss b/src/amo/components/TooltipMenu/styles.scss
index 32c7ec222c..c8730105df 100644
--- a/src/amo/components/TooltipMenu/styles.scss
+++ b/src/amo/components/TooltipMenu/styles.scss
@@ -90,7 +90,7 @@
     a,
     a:link,
     button {
-      &:not(.Button) {
+      &:not(.Button):not([disabled]) {
         @include font-medium;
 
         cursor: pointer;
diff --git a/tests/unit/amo/components/TestAddonReviewCard.js b/tests/unit/amo/components/TestAddonReviewCard.js
index 66e602dd8e..2a1c0c0949 100644
--- a/tests/unit/amo/components/TestAddonReviewCard.js
+++ b/tests/unit/amo/components/TestAddonReviewCard.js
@@ -1485,6 +1485,11 @@ describe(__filename, () => {
 
         await openFlagMenu();
 
+        expect(
+          screen.getByRole('button', {
+            name: 'This is spam',
+          }),
+        ).not.toBeDisabled();
         expect(
           // It would have to be a 'button' if `enableFeatureFeedbackFormLinks`
           // was set to `false`.
@@ -1492,6 +1497,11 @@ describe(__filename, () => {
             name: 'This contains inappropriate language',
           }),
         ).toBeInTheDocument();
+        expect(
+          screen.getByRole('button', {
+            name: 'This is a bug report or support request',
+          }),
+        ).not.toBeDisabled();
       });
 
       it('can be configured with an openerClass', () => {
@@ -1525,6 +1535,60 @@ describe(__filename, () => {
         ).toBeInTheDocument();
       });
 
+      describe('when enableFeatureFeedbackFormLinks is enabled', () => {
+        beforeEach(() => {
+          const fakeConfig = getMockConfig({
+            enableFeatureFeedbackFormLinks: true,
+          });
+          config.get.mockImplementation((key) => {
+            return fakeConfig[key];
+          });
+        });
+
+        it('shows the menu for signed-out users', async () => {
+          render({ review: _setReview() });
+
+          await openFlagMenu();
+
+          expect(
+            screen.queryByRole('link', { name: 'Log in to flag this review' }),
+          ).not.toBeInTheDocument();
+          expect(
+            screen.getByRole('button', {
+              name: 'This is spam',
+            }),
+          ).toBeDisabled();
+          expect(
+            screen.getByRole('link', {
+              name: 'This contains inappropriate language',
+            }),
+          ).toBeInTheDocument();
+          expect(
+            screen.getByRole('button', {
+              name: 'This is a bug report or support request',
+            }),
+          ).toBeDisabled();
+        });
+
+        it('shows the menu for signed-in users', async () => {
+          dispatchSignInActionsWithStore({ store, userId: 999 });
+          render({ review: _setReview() });
+
+          await openFlagMenu();
+
+          expect(
+            screen.getByRole('button', {
+              name: 'This is spam',
+            }),
+          ).not.toBeDisabled();
+          expect(
+            screen.getByRole('button', {
+              name: 'This is a bug report or support request',
+            }),
+          ).not.toBeDisabled();
+        });
+      });
+
       it('prompts you to flag a developer response after login', async () => {
         renderNestedReply();