diff --git a/lib/settings_base.py b/lib/settings_base.py
index 2bb000e88d..c8f8c81ce8 100644
--- a/lib/settings_base.py
+++ b/lib/settings_base.py
@@ -74,6 +74,7 @@ MANAGERS = ADMINS
 FLIGTAR = 'amo-admins@mozilla.org'
 EDITORS_EMAIL = 'amo-editors@mozilla.org'
 SENIOR_EDITORS_EMAIL = 'amo-admin-reviews@mozilla.org'
+THEMES_EMAIL = 'background-themes@mozilla.com'
 MARKETPLACE_EMAIL = 'amo-marketplace@mozilla.org'
 ABUSE_EMAIL = 'marketplace-abuse@mozilla.org'
 NOBODY_EMAIL = 'nobody@mozilla.org'
diff --git a/mkt/reviewers/tasks.py b/mkt/reviewers/tasks.py
index 44a213bbce..c48bf6c5c9 100644
--- a/mkt/reviewers/tasks.py
+++ b/mkt/reviewers/tasks.py
@@ -56,7 +56,7 @@ def send_mail(cleaned_data, theme_lock):
     elif action == rvw.ACTION_FLAG:
         subject = _('Theme submission flagged for review')
         template = 'reviewers/themes/emails/flag_reviewer.html'
-        emails = [settings.SENIOR_EDITORS_EMAIL]
+        emails = [settings.THEMES_EMAIL]
         theme.addon.update(status=amo.STATUS_REVIEW_PENDING)
 
         # Send another email to the user notifying them that their Theme has
@@ -64,7 +64,7 @@ def send_mail(cleaned_data, theme_lock):
         send_mail_jinja(_('A problem with your Theme submission'),
                         'reviewers/themes/emails/flag_user.html', context,
                         recipient_list=emails,
-                        headers={'Reply-To': theme_lock.reviewer.email})
+                        headers={'Reply-To': settings.THEMES_EMAIL})
 
     elif action == rvw.ACTION_MOREINFO:
         subject = _('A question about your Theme submission')
@@ -83,4 +83,4 @@ def send_mail(cleaned_data, theme_lock):
 
     send_mail_jinja(subject, template, context,
                     recipient_list=emails,
-                    headers={'Reply-To': theme_lock.reviewer.email})
+                    headers={'Reply-To': settings.THEMES_EMAIL})
diff --git a/mkt/reviewers/tests/test_views.py b/mkt/reviewers/tests/test_views.py
index c210851dbd..43aac97599 100644
--- a/mkt/reviewers/tests/test_views.py
+++ b/mkt/reviewers/tests/test_views.py
@@ -2116,7 +2116,7 @@ class ThemeReviewTestMixin(object):
                  'theme': themes[0],
                  'reviewer_email': u'reviewer0@mozilla.com',
                  'base_url': 'http://testserver'},
-                headers={'Reply-To': u'reviewer0@mozilla.com'},
+                headers={'Reply-To': settings.THEMES_EMAIL},
                 recipient_list=set([])),
             mock.call('A problem with your Theme submission',
                 'reviewers/themes/emails/flag_user.html',
@@ -2124,23 +2124,23 @@ class ThemeReviewTestMixin(object):
                  'comment': u'flag',
                  'theme': themes[1],
                  'base_url': 'http://testserver'},
-                headers={'Reply-To': u'reviewer0@mozilla.com'},
-                recipient_list=['amo-admin-reviews@mozilla.org']),
+                headers={'Reply-To': settings.THEMES_EMAIL},
+                recipient_list=[settings.THEMES_EMAIL]),
             mock.call('Theme submission flagged for review',
                 'reviewers/themes/emails/flag_reviewer.html',
                 {'reason': None,
                  'comment': u'flag',
                  'theme': themes[1],
                  'base_url': 'http://testserver'},
-                headers={'Reply-To': u'reviewer0@mozilla.com'},
-                recipient_list=['amo-admin-reviews@mozilla.org']),
+                headers={'Reply-To': settings.THEMES_EMAIL},
+                recipient_list=[settings.THEMES_EMAIL]),
             mock.call('A problem with your Theme submission',
                 'reviewers/themes/emails/reject.html',
                 {'reason': None,
                  'comment': u'duplicate',
                  'theme': themes[2],
                  'base_url': 'http://testserver'},
-                headers={'Reply-To': u'reviewer0@mozilla.com'},
+                headers={'Reply-To': settings.THEMES_EMAIL},
                  recipient_list=set([])),
             mock.call('A problem with your Theme submission',
                 'reviewers/themes/emails/reject.html',
@@ -2148,7 +2148,7 @@ class ThemeReviewTestMixin(object):
                  'comment': u'reject',
                  'theme': themes[3],
                  'base_url': 'http://testserver'},
-                headers={'Reply-To': u'reviewer0@mozilla.com'},
+                headers={'Reply-To': settings.THEMES_EMAIL},
                 recipient_list=set([])),
             mock.call('Thanks for submitting your Theme',
                 'reviewers/themes/emails/approve.html',
@@ -2156,7 +2156,7 @@ class ThemeReviewTestMixin(object):
                  'comment': u'',
                  'theme': themes[4],
                  'base_url': 'http://testserver'},
-                headers={'Reply-To': u'reviewer0@mozilla.com'},
+                headers={'Reply-To': settings.THEMES_EMAIL},
                 recipient_list=set([]))
         ]
         eq_(send_mail_jinja_mock.call_args_list[0], expected_calls[0])