This patch cleans up the DBus utilitys and helper classes. All functions
for sending have been removed. Their users have been converted to the
new methods in RawDBusConnection. Include statements have been cleaned
up as well. Some methods of DBusMessageRefPtr have been moved from the
header to the source file to prevent inclusion of the DBus API from within
the header file.
This patch adds methods for sending DBus messages to the class
RawDBusConnection. There are 3 types of interfaces.
- Send Sends a message over DBus. No error checking or
handling of replies is performed. These methods
do not block the sending thread.
- SendWithReply Sends a message over DBus and runs a call-back
function for the reply. This should be the default
case for most scenarios. These methods do not
block the sending thread.
- SendWithError Sends a message over DBus and waits for the reply
or an error. This interface has only been added for
some existing code that can safely block the sending
thread. Don't use it in new code.
These 3 types of interfaces represent what is currently used of the
existing send functions in DBusUtils. When all users have been converted
to the new methods, the interfaces in DBusUtils can be removed.
For replacing the Bluetooth command thread with a LazyIdleThread,
we need to make sure that the DBus service thread is shutdown from
within the main thread.
This patch changes the DBus stop code to cleanup the DBusThread
structure from the service thread to prevent race conditions during
shutdown. The DBus service thread itself gets shutdown from the main
thread to fulfill the requirements of LazyIdleThread. The patch also
makes sure that it's not possible to accidently dispatch a runnable
while the DBus thread terminates.
RawDBusConnection incorrectly uses detail::RefCounted, which it
shouldn't. This patch converts it to use AtomicRefCounted instead.
--HG--
extra : rebase_source : 229bbbae3b43a47b362ab73dba5d1134a5ae1dac
Instances of RawDBusConnection can now be contained in nsRefPtr. This
allows to share the DBus connection among multiple threads.
--HG--
extra : rebase_source : fb24472b3b55e77abc7354f17ef679661f62b7fb
The method BluetoothDBusService::GetServiceChannel currently blocks the
Bluetooth command thread while waiting for a DBus message, before it
dispatches a runnable to the main thread.
With this patch, the DBus message is processed asyncronously, and the
runnable gets dispatched from the DBus reply handler.
--HG--
extra : rebase_source : 24519b7dd8d59fcbbf78436092610c8db195f6a2
Handler functions for DBus replies sometimes need several data fields
or need to keep state over replies for multiple messages. The DBus API
itself only allows for a single pointer to user data.
The class DBusReplyHandler is a base class for implementing DBus reply-
message handlers. Users of DBus can inherit from this class to implement
message-specific handlers.
--HG--
extra : rebase_source : 91c5f6e8d365922fd3b52fbaf502052f86274f16
The this commit moves the sending of blocking DBus messages to the
DBus thread. This allows us to avoid concurrency problems within the
DBus library, which is not explicitly thread-safe.
As a side note, I'd like to mention that blocking in distributed
systems simply doesn't work. The dbus library is especially broken
in this regard as it delays all unrelated messages until the reply
for the blocking request has been received. A future commit should
implement this functionality with an asyncronous call and make the
related thread wait for the reply.
The DBus send operation simply sends a DBus message without further
processing of replies. If the sender is interested in a reply, the
respective serial number can be returned. In this case, the sending
operation (and only the sending) is serialized with the calling
thread.
The class DBusConnectionSendWithReplyTask has been renamed to
DBusConnectionSendWithReplyRunnable, which better fits its purpose. The
internal callback function and data has been move into the implementation
of DBusConnectionSendWithReplyRunnable. Additionally, there is now an
abstract base class for DBus send runnables. This class will become useful
for implementing send classes with different policies.
This patch finally fixes bug 827888 were a message's reply was
received before the respective handler function could be installed.
The patch adds the class DBusConnectionSendWithReplyTask, which
asyncronously sends a DBus message and installs the reply's handler
function. The DBus utility functions for asyncronous messages create
an instance of this class and dispatch it to the DBus thread. This
intercepts the DBusPollTask, so no DBus replies can be received until
the dispatched DBusConnectionSendWithReplyTask has finished.
The new function allows to schedule nsRunnables to an existing DBus
thread. This intercepts the running instance of DBusPollTask and
makes the DBus thread process the dispatched runnable. The intercepted
poll task automatically continues polling once all pending runnables
have been processed.
This patch replaces the DBus EventLoop function by an instance
of DBusPollTask. It also cleans up the initialization and shutdown
code of the DBusThread.
This patch adds class DBusPollTask. The DBusPollTask class is an
nsRunnable for receiving DBus messages. It is intended to run in
a separate thread that is dedicated to DBus only.
The Run function of the poll task resembles the DBus EventLoop
function, but allows to intercept execution in favor of other
nsRunnables. Afterwards the DBusPollTask continues.
We intent to run the DBus thread's EventLoop function as separate
nsRunnable, but the function also contains code for initializing
sockets that are used for internal communication.
With this patch the socket initialization has been moved to the
setup function. This reduces the EventLoop function to plain event
handling.
There were merges in configure.in and some Makefile.in. None had any
conflicts. I spot verified the Makefile.in changes and confirmed that
the changes did not touch any DIRS* variables.
If a DBUS call completes before we can set the notifier function, the
call's response never gets handled. To workaround this problem, we now
call the notifier explicitly if the call completes this early.
It can still happen that the call's response gets lost, but this
workaround greatly improves the success rate for our problem of handling
errors during Bluetooth device pairing; from maybe 10% to 75%.
Eric Chou
Ms2ger
Thomas Zimmermann
Wes Kocher
Mike Hommey
Brian O'Keefe
Birunthan Mohanathas
Trevor Saunders
Mike Shal
Kyle Machulis
Gina Yeh
Gregory Szorc
Aryeh Gregor